A major national trial of a different way of treating mental health crises has found that patients cared for under the Open Dialogue model were far less likely to end up in hospital. The findings, published in The Lancet Psychiatry, come from the ODDESSI trial, sponsored by North East London NHS Foundation Trust (NELFT) and led by Professor Steve Pilling of UCL, with funding from the National Institute for Health and Care Research.

Open Dialogue turns the usual crisis response inside out: instead of assessing a person alone and deciding a treatment for them, clinicians bring the individual together with family, carers and others in their support network to plan and review care jointly, with a strong emphasis on continuity and shared decision-making.

The trial randomised 494 people who presented to mental health services in crisis to either Open Dialogue or treatment as usual. On the primary measure — time to relapse after recovery — there was no difference between the groups, and the researchers report that plainly. But on hospital use the gap was wide: people treated with Open Dialogue had more than three times the odds of never being admitted to psychiatric inpatient care, and lower odds of being re-referred to crisis services over the two-year follow-up.

The researchers say the pattern suggests Open Dialogue may also reduce NHS costs, by resolving crises in the community rather than in a ward. For health systems struggling with scarce psychiatric beds, a model that keeps people out of hospital without worse relapse outcomes is a result worth taking seriously.