A Quebec novel at the centre of an AI-authorship row is staying in limbo. The author accused of using AI has abandoned the effort to document the novel's origins amid the allegations, the publisher says, in reporting carried by CBC Montreal and Global News this weekend.

The case turns on a burden of proof publishing has never had to formalize: once readers or critics allege that a manuscript was machine-generated, what evidence settles it — drafts, files, correspondence, testimony? Walking away from that documentation effort leaves the allegation permanently unanswered, whatever the truth of how the book was written.

Publishers across the industry are improvising their answers at the same time: disclosure rules for AI assistance, contract clauses about machine-generated text, and editorial processes that can show a human drafting trail if a title is challenged.

For readers, the Quebec case is a preview of a recurring argument rather than a one-off scandal. As AI writing tools improve, “prove you wrote it” is becoming a question authors may be asked in public — and this weekend's answer, from one author at least, was to stop trying.